A fire chief says he battled Christian discrimination. Supreme Court declines to take his case
Manage your account
WASHINGTON – Ronald Hittle was laid off as fire chief of Stockton, Calif., after facing allegations of misconduct, including an anonymous letter describing him as a “corrupt, racist, lying, religious fanatic.” One of the issues that led to his termination: he had attended, with other managers, a church-sponsored summit for Christian leaders during work hours.
Hittle tried to sue, arguing he was fired because of his Christian religion, but lower courts said he didn’t have a strong enough case to go to trial.
Hittle, though, contends the test the Supreme Court established more than 50 years ago for evaluating workplace discrimination allegations needs to be reexamined.
The Supreme Court on Monday declined to take his case, skirting a potential showdown over religion in in the workplace during a year that the Court is testing the limits of religion in schools, and religion-related tax exemptions.
Justices Clarence Thomas and Neil Gorsuch said they would have heard the appeal.
Thomas wrote that Hittle had plenty evidence of discriminatory intent, and his case would have allowed the court to offer clear guidance on how to determine when workplace discrimination cases can move forward.
More: Supreme Court appears likely to side with straight woman in `reverse discrimination' case
Hittle was fired in 2011 after city investigator concluded Hittle lacked effectiveness and judgment, failed to report time off, engaged in favoritism and had attended with other managers a religious event while on the job, among other findings.
The event was a church-sponsored summit for Christian leaders, which Hittle said he went to because the city directed him to get leadership training.
Hittle argues his attendance at the Global Leadership Summit was the main reason he was fired and alleged the deputy city manager had accused him of being part of a “Christian Coalition.”
The San Francisco-based 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals said Hittle hadn’t persuaded them that the city’s stated reasons for firing him were a cover story. The court also said there wasn’t enough evidence that his supervisors made discriminatory remarks.
Hittle said the appeals court incorrectly required him to prove the city’s stated justifications were bogus.
“When an employer acts for a discriminatory reason, it cannot automatically avoid liability just because lawful reasons also motivated it,” his attorneys told the court.
More: 'Wolf in sheep's clothing'? How a USPS worker's fight over Sunday shifts could change your workplace.
The city says Hittle is mischaracterizing the appeals court’s decision and there’s no reason to reconsider the court’s landmark 1973 decision, McDonnell Douglas Corp. v. Green, a “settled touchstone of employment-discrimination law.”
“The City’s reasons for terminating (Hittle) were well-documented and entirely appropriate for the Ninth Circuit to rely upon,” the city’s lawyers told the court.
This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: Supreme Court rejects fire chief's religious discrimination case
DWIGHT, Ill. — Nature has taken over the vacated Dwight Correctional Center, where a thin forest of spindly trees covers a 160-acre campus that old photos show once featured well-tended lawns and stately oaks. The decaying old prison has become an unauthorized soundstage for YouTubers. In a video titled “We Got Trapped Inside an Abandoned Prison by Police,” a user whose profile promises “crazy ...
Democratic California Gov. Gavin Newsom is no stranger to going against the grain on significant social issues.
Vice President JD Vance didn't seem enthusiastic about the length of President Trump's joint address to Congress on Tuesday in a hot mic moment.
Fox News host Maria Bartiromo pressed President Trump on whether he is “comfortable” with the idea that Ukraine “may not survive” the war with Russia. Trump sat down for an interview with Bartiromo to discuss his tariff plan, and how his administration is off to a busy start. Bartiromo said she spoke with Polish President…
A top acting State Department official deleted at least half a dozen tweets that ridiculed his new boss, Secretary of State Marco Rubio, including ones calling him “low IQ” and repeating a false rumor about Rubio’s sexuality.
Meghan also shared photos of herself with her mother and with husband Prince Harry
"Here's where the story turns," Michael Cohen wrote.
We didn't really know our neighbor of 11 years until my husband asked for a favor. Now, he's like a grandfather to my kids.
The president posted a column from conservative activist Charlie Kirk telling people to stop complaining about egg prices.
House Speaker Mike Johnson (R-La.) said during a radio interview that Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky has done a complete “about-face” on the U.S.-Ukraine minerals deal that was not signed after a heated meeting between the two delegations late last month. “I’m really grateful and glad that Zelensky, in the last several days, has done an…
Duffy also rebuffed Musk’s claim that air traffic controllers were hired from DEI initiatives.
"I had supported Trump in the past, but after he took office, I began to notice that many of his policies seemed to target individuals like me — supporters who found themselves laid off."
Just five months after the women told investigative reporter Jeff German about an alleged toxic workplace, the journalist was killed.
If you don’t believe in aliens yet, you’re behind. The United States has been secretly working to capture UAPs — unidentified anomalous phenomena, the more formal term for UFOs — since as early as 1947, according to many high-ranking figures throughout the government, military and intelligence community. There is evidence and documentation of all kinds …
Secretary of State presses on with Trump administration’s efforts to make European nations profess gratitude
Trump’s defense secretary ends a 1965 policy barring racial segregation from contract facilities
The Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA)—which helps the country prep for, respond to, and recover from disasters—announced on Friday that it is canceling all in-person training offered by its National Fire Academy. It’s a move that directly defies a federal judge’s order to resume spending, and not for the first time. The National Fire Academy provides free training for fire and emergency services personnel to ensure the country is prepared for the next climate-related disaster. Fire has
To billionaire Elon Musk and his cost-cutting team at the Department of Government Efficiency, Karen Ortiz may just be one of many faceless bureaucrats. Ortiz is an administrative judge at the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission -- the federal agency in charge of enforcing U.S. workplace anti-discrimination laws that has undergone tumultuous change since President Donald Trump took office. Like millions of other federal employees, Ortiz opened an ominous email on Jan. 28 titled “Fork in the Road" giving them the option to resign from their positions as part of the government’s cost-cutting measures directed by Trump and carried out by DOGE under Musk, an unelected official.
After 29 long days of searching, the body of Atlanta educator, Gary Jones, has been found on Lake Oconee.
Gary Jones and his fiancée Joycelyn Wilson went missing during a boat trip on Lake Oconee on Feb. 8
Pick a side Donald Trump‘s relationship with the U.K. has become frosty after King Charles showered Ukrainian president Volodymyr Zelensky with praise at his country home, Sandringham—just days after Trump’s highly public Oval Office clash with the Ukrainian leader. The photographs of the king standing shoulder to shoulder with the Ukrainian leader have made Trump’s invite for a state visit to Britain—delivered with a flourish by British Prime Minister Keir Starmer in front of TV cameras—seem “l
Authorities in the U.K. are coordinating an emergency response in the North Sea near East Yorkshire, England
The Colorado congresswoman also received a blunt reminder, or two.
A new report outlines the degree to which the Biden administration injected DEI into the federal government as the Trump administration pushes to eliminate it.
Ruth Ben-Ghiat also listed the Trump moves that show "we’re certainly headed toward" autocracy.
Department of Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem said on Sunday that she knows Mexican and Canadian leaders have their own “political environments” but that President Trump “means business” on tariffs. “We all recognize that each one of these leaders has political environments in their home countries as well, but President Trump means business, and he…
For two days, Rihab Kamel and her family hid terrified in their bathroom in the city of Baniyas as armed men stormed the neighbourhood, pursuing members of Syria's Alawite minority.That same day, armed men entered his brother's building 100 metres (yards) away.
"There is a period of transition because what we're doing is very big."
Trump has repeatedly criticized Europe's defense spending and previously threatened to leave NATO if allies didn't pay more.
Activists sprayed red paint across clubhouse, dug up greens and daubed slogans on walls
Family Nissan in New York gifted Makayla Starks with a new Nissan Leaf, an all-electric car, after seeing her story in the news
Federal immigration authorities arrested a Palestinian activist Saturday who played a prominent role in Columbia University’s protests against Israel, a significant escalation in the Trump administration’s pledge to detain and deport student activists. Mahmoud Khalil, a graduate student at Columbia until this past December, was inside his university-owned apartment Saturday night when several Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents entered and took him into custody, his attorney, Amy Greer, told The Associated Press. Greer said she spoke by phone with one of the ICE agents during the arrest, who said they were acting on State Department orders to revoke Khalil’s student visa.
The top Trump adviser sprinkled in some fawning praise of the president on Fox News.
Americans think Donald Trump is like one particular "South Park" character, said Harry Enten.
"Our job is not to cut Social Security, as many of our Republican colleagues in Congress want to do."
His last meal was a single serving of four pieces of fried chicken, green beans, mashed potatoes and sweet tea.
Moosehead Breweries said it's now selling the "Presidential Pack," of 1,461 cans of its Canadian Lagers, one for every day of Trump's remaining term.
The U.S. has stopped sharing satellite intelligence with Ukraine
Elon Musk's supposedly "anti-woke" chatbot, Grok, keeps spewing outputs that are hilariously opposite of the billionaire's views — including that President Donald Trump is likely a Russian asset. Responding to a prompt from Arizona Republic columnist EJ Montini, Musk's "maximally truth-seeking" AI, which is built into X, said after a shockingly in-depth analysis that the probability of the president being in the pocket of Vladimir Putin is between 75 and 85 percent. After Montini asked Grok to r
Some of Secretary of State Marco Rubio’s former Democratic colleagues are already expressing regret over their votes in support of the former senator. But his boosters on both sides of the aisle aren’t ready to give up on his ability to influence President Trump. “Long term he will have a real influence. Short term, I…
“Telework often improves performance by eliminating unnecessary commute time and reducing the distractions of an office environment.”
EU countries that share a border with Russia are moving to withdraw from international bans on cluster bombs and landmines as they seek to build up deterrence.
Neighbors are speaking out after uncovering the latest development in a criminal trend that’s been hitting cities all around Southern California: hidden cameras. In a very disconcerting discovery, the daughter of an Encino couple – who wants to remain anonymous for their safety – found a hidden camera in the bushes outside of their home […]
Secretary of State Marco Rubio said Monday the Trump administration had finished its six-week purge of programs of the six-decade-old U.S. Agency for International Development, and said he would move the 18% of aid and development programs that survived under the State Department. Rubio made the announcement in a post on X. It marked one of his relatively few public comments on what has been a historic shift away from U.S. foreign aid and development, executed by Trump political appointees at State and Elon Musk's Department of Government Efficiency teams.
Gas station shootout leaves multiple hurt in New Smyrna Beach
The GOP struggles to defend the unpopular Trump administration’s policies.
Republicans and Democrats have sparred over solutions regarding Social Security and Medicare for years, as the bureaucratic red tape of federal law is thick. One such advocate for Social Security...
Republican senators signed a scathing letter to the American Bar Association, calling out the organization's alleged political biases against President Donald Trump.
All employees of the Department of Health and Human Services, overseen by Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr., received unsigned emails Friday night offering them a “voluntary separation incentive payment.”
Trump and his allies have flaunted their support for far-right movements at home and abroad. We cannot allow them to succeed.
