Connect with us

Facebook

Facebook vs Twitter, Who Made Progress in Fighting Hate Speech?

DJ Kamal Mustafa

Published

on

Facebook vs Twitter Guy Rosen facebook hate speech

Facebook vs Twitter: Who made progress in fighting Hate Speech? You will find out in this Article of the Facebook Transparency Report with additional input from Mr. Guy Rosen, VP of Integrity ‘The European Commission. Guy Rosen is Facebook’s vice president of product management and site integrity manager.

Have you read this story? https://emeatribune.com/instagram-policy-questions-with-head-of-instagram-communications-apac/

Advertisement
  • I have seen lots of banned outfits accounts on Twitter who had claimed responsibilities for terror attacks on armed forces
  • Twitter take action but it takes days to review the report and sometimes they say “No violation” even if there is clear graphics violence
  • Twitter may have changed its policies in 2021 but still, Twitter have to monitor the activities of banned outfits

Facebook is a transparent platform, and Facebook’s policies are better than other social media sites, such as Twitter and Facebook, which regularly publish reports to give our community visibility into community standards, enforcement, government requests, and internet disruptions. Facebook doesn’t allow hate speech on their platforms, including Instagram, and they have a strict policy on that. But on the other hand on Twitter you will see terrorist accounts, hate mongers, rapists, and anti-government and anti-religious accounts but you won’t be able to see those accounts on Facebook and this is my personal experience, that is why I said in the beginning that “Facebook Policies are far better than any other” and here “other” means Twitter.

  • Facebook has tripled the size of teams working in safety and security since 2016 to over 40,000 people
  • Facebook team reviews reports of hate speech 24 hours a day, seven days a week
  • The company has also invested heavily in Artificial Intelligence Technology to proactively detect hate speech in more languages.

Facebook has invested in new technologies and improved the system to find hate speech content and remove it from their platform. According to Facebook’s Vice President of Integrity, Mr. Guy Rosen, “We release transparency reports every six months to share our progress with the general public so people can see where and what we are doing and how we are protecting our users.” Mr. Guy Rosen further said, “Not every company does this, but we think it’s important to be transparent about how we’re doing and allow people to hold us accountable.”  

Guy Rosen said Facebook had signed the European Commission’s code of conduct on countering illegal hate speech online, which means the European Commission runs independent tests regularly and sees which companies who have signed the code of conduct are removing the content quickly and effectively. Last week’s fifth report was published by the European Commission, which you can read by going to this link. According to the report, Facebook is reviewing reports of hate speech faster than ever before and removing hate speech content efficiently and transparently.

The European Commission Report on Facebook vs Twitter

 

facebook vs twitter Facebook Transparency Report

Notifications of illegal hate speech Facebook vs Twitter

Advertisement

According to the report, Facebook received the largest amount of notifications which is 2348 while Twitter only received 1396. A total of 4364 notifications were submitted to the IT companies taking part in the Code of Conduct. (This data is of 6 weeks from 4 November to 13 December 2019).

 Time to assess notifications on Facebook vs Twitter

According to the report, Facebook assessed notifications in less than 24 hours in 95.7% of the cases and 3.4% in less than 48 hours, while Twitter 76.6% and 8.7%, respectively. But the winning trophy at the time of assessment also goes to Facebook.

Advertisement

Removal rates of Facebook vs Twitter

71 percent of the content was removed by the IT Companies but 29 percent remained online. According to the report, Facebook removed 87.6% of the content, which means Facebook removes hate speech and other violations in 24 hours with an average of 88 percent, while Twitter, as usual, is in the second position but on removing the content Twitter stands nowhere yes I repeat Twitter stands nowhere. The European Commission report says Facebook has made further progress on removals compared to last year, while Twitter is not on target and the removal rate is lower than in 2019.

EMEA TRIBUNE can prove it right now by giving you two examples so you can understand better

Advertisement

1) Five terrorist attacks on Pakistan Rangers Sindh (Law Enforcement Agency) in June 2020, a responsibility of this attack was made through two Twitter accounts and none is suspended even though Twitter has verified the chairman of the banned terrorist organization last year. I would like to mention here that the banned terrorist organization is a Global Terrorist Organization designated by the US Department of Justice and the Government of Pakistan. thousands of people were reporting to Twitter to take down the account, who had not only claimed responsibility but vowed to kill more law enforcement officers, but as usual, Twitter did nothing.

Attack on Pakistan Rangers Sindh in Karachi

 

Advertisement

 

2) On Monday 29, June 2020 4 terrorists attacked the building of the Pakistan Stock Exchange. Fortunately, the terrorist attack was foiled by the law enforcement agency but 4 security personnel were martyred and 4 terrorists also died by the agencies in 8 minutes. According to the BBC’s banned terrorist organization BLA, which has claimed responsibility for terrorist attacks on Twitter, an account has shared images of the attackers and vowed to kill more people. Twitter took 24 hours to suspend the account but many accounts are still active in that group.

https://emeatribune.com/pakistan-stock-exchange-attack-foiled-four-terrorists-killed-in-8-minutes/

Advertisement

 

Feedback on users and transparency of Facebook vs Twitter

Facebook Transparency Report: On average, the IT companies responded with feedback to 67.1% of the notifications received. This is slightly higher than in the previous monitoring exercise (65.4%). According to the report, only Facebook is informing users systematically (93.7% of notifications received feedback) while Twitter stands nowhere in front of Facebook

Facebook’s Response to the European Commission Report

Vice President of Integrity Mr. Guy Rosen delightedly said in a blog post 

 

Advertisement

European Commission Vice President Vera Jourova and Commissioner Didier Reynders recognized our progress in fighting hate speech on our platform, and we will continue to develop new tools and invest in technology to detect and remove it.

Facebook Director Miss. Leigh Thomas also said in a post

Really Proud to Read The European Commission Report”

 

If you like my story on Facebook Transparency Report (Facebook vs Twitter) then please Follow me on Instagram and Facebook

Advertisement

DJ Kamal Mustafa is a Music Producer, DJ, Pakistani Filmmaker, and Journalist. Has Made six Animated Films and Released 18 Music Albums for Pakistani and Bollywood Celebrities. The latest animated film on Cyber Awareness has been released by DJ Kamal Mustafa, a project for NR3C.GOV.PK (National Response Center For Cyber Crime) FIA Cyber Crime Wing. I have been featured in The News, Geo News, Dunya News, Gulf News, Global Village Space, and in many newspapers and news blogs. I am writing for Pakistan Today, Times of India, Capital TV, Daily Times, and other news outlets.

Continue Reading
Advertisement
Advertisement

Breaking News

Advertisement

Today’s Top Picks

Support US

Support Independent Journalism with a donation (Paypal, BTC, USDT, ETH)

$1.00
Personal Info

Donation Total: $1.00

Advertisement