Connect with us


Here’s why the smart money is betting on value stocks to outperform growth

News Agencies



You should be skeptical of the growth story that periodically captures stock investors’ attention. That’s because the companies that Wall Street believes will grow the fastest in the future rarely live up to the lofty expectations investors put on them.

The latest of bout of this growth-stock fever occurred this week. On Wednesday, after Federal Reserve Chairman Jerome Powell hinted that the Fed would slow the pace of future rate hikes, investors jumped on the growth bandwagon. The SPDR S&P 500 Growth ETF

gained 4.3% in that day’s session, far outpacing the 1.9% return of the SPDR S&P 500 Value ETF
Meanwhile, Invesco QQQ Trust
which is heavily weighted with tech stocks that in essence are growth stocks on steroids, gained even more, 4.6%.

On the surface, investors’ reaction makes a certain amount of sense, since the present value of future years’ earnings increases as interest rates decline. Since a greater share of growth stocks’ earnings than value stocks’ earnings traces to future years, growth stocks should benefit disproportionately when rates decline.

Or so the growth stock rationale goes. The Achilles’ Heel of this rationale is the assumption that growth stocks’ earnings will actually grow faster than for value stocks. More often than not, this isn’t the case.


This is difficult for investors to accept, since growth stocks are often those whose trailing years’ earnings growth has been well-above average. But just because a company’s past earnings have grown at a brisk pace doesn’t mean they will continue growing at that pace in the future.

We should actually expect that earnings will not be able to keep that pace, according to several major research projects over the past couple of decades. One of the first, which appeared 25 years ago in the Journal of Finance, was conducted by Louis K. C. Chan (chair of the Department of Finance at the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign), and Jason Karceski and Josef Lakonishok (of LSV Asset Management). Upon analyzing data for U.S. stocks from 1951 through 1997, they found that “there is no persistence in long-term earnings growth beyond chance.”

Two researchers at Verdad, the money-management firm, recently updated this Journal of Finance study to focus on the 25 years since it was published. They are Brian Chingono, Verdad’s director of quantitative research, and Greg Obenshain, partner and director of credit at the firm. They reached the same conclusion as the earlier study: “[W]e found little to no evidence of persistence in earnings growth, beyond chance, over the long term,” they concluded.


The table below summarizes what the Verdad researchers found for companies whose earnings growth in a given year were in the top 25%. They looked to see how many of them, on average, were in the top half for EBITDA growth in each of the subsequent five years. That’s a rather low bar over which to jump, and yet many, in some years most, failed to clear it.

% of top quartile of firms for earnings growth in a given year that are above median for EBITDA growth at… Expectation based on randomness/pure chance Difference from pure chance (in percentage points)
End of subsequent year 1 48.8% 50.0% -1.2
End of subsequent year 2 23.0% 25.0% -2.0
End of subsequent year 3 12.3% 12.5% -0.2
End of subsequent year 4 6.8% 6.3% +0.5
End of subsequent year 5 4.0% 3.1% +0.9

Note carefully that these results don’t mean that the overall stock market shouldn’t have rallied this week in reaction to the Fed’s expected pivot. Instead, these studies speak to the relative performance of value- and growth stocks. Growth shouldn’t outperform value just because interest rates may be falling, just as value shouldn’t outperform growth just because rates may be rising.

So keep this in mind the next time the Fed pivots. If the market reacts by skewing heavily towards either growth or value, a gutsy contrarian bet would be to predict that the reaction will soon correct itself. This is why contrarians right now are betting on value over growth.


Mark Hulbert is a regular contributor to MarketWatch. His Hulbert Ratings tracks investment newsletters that pay a flat fee to be audited. He can be reached at

Also read: Fed ‘pivot’ to lower interest rates will be bullish for stocks. But timing is everything.

Plus: The key word for investors to decipher the Fed’s next move is ‘moderation,’ strategist Ed Yardeni says.

Continue Reading


Breaking News

Editor Pick’s

Latest Entertainment

Entertainment1 hour ago

Britney Spears asks fans to respect her privacy after police welfare check: ‘Things went a little too far’

Britney Spears says things went “too far” after fans called police to her home. (Photo: FilmMagic) Britney Spears broke her...

Entertainment2 hours ago

Amy Robach and T.J. Holmes mediating with ABC amid suspension: ‘It’s all a huge mess,’ says source

T.J. Holmes and Amy Robach’s fate at GMA3 unclear as the two begin a mediation with ABC. (Photo: Getty Images)...

Entertainment6 hours ago

‘Shazam 2’ Trailer Highlights the Villainous Daughters of Atlas

A new Shazam! Fury of the Gods trailer has been released, giving fans a closer look at the upcoming DC...

Entertainment6 hours ago

Salma Hayek’s see-through dress leaves Channing Tatum speechless: ‘I have no comment’

Salma Hayek stuns in a see-through dress at the premiere for Magic Mike’s Last Dance. (Photo: Getty Images) Salma Hayek...

Entertainment6 hours ago

Succession season 4 teaser promises more warring, more Wambsgans, and a wedding

Succession will return for its fourth season March 24, HBO announced today. And we also got us our first, predictably...

Entertainment6 hours ago

Sam Smith Says ‘Changing’ Their Pronouns ‘Felt Like Coming Home’ — but Had Its Challenges

Sam Smith is reflecting on their journey since coming out as non-binary in 2019. In an exclusive clip shared with...

Entertainment7 hours ago

Why ‘Cheers’ favorite John Ratzenberger makes a rare TV appearance in ‘Poker Face’

Natasha Lyonne and John Ratzenberger in the second episode of Poker Face. (Photo: Evans Vestal Ward/Peacock) It’s been 30 years...

Entertainment7 hours ago

This is no joke, this is catering! See Adam Scott and crew in Party Down season 3 first trailer

The gang’s back together in the first trailer for the long-awaited third season of cult fave Party Down. Original stars...


Latest Sports

Sports46 mins ago

Why Warriors sent Moses Moody to G League for first time this season

Moses Moody is going to the G League for the first time this season. Here's why.

Sports1 hour ago

How 49ers can exploit Eagles’ biggest flaw to win NFC title game, per Greg Papa

Greg Papa breaks down how the 49ers can take advantage of one of the Eagles' biggest weaknesses in the NFC...

News2 hours ago

How Raptors stifled Kings star in impressive win

On the latest episode of "Strictly Hoops", C.J. Miles and Amit Mann discuss the schemes and strategy behind the Raptors...

Sports2 hours ago

Slight problem: Will Mahomes use chatter as fuel?

Unlike Tom Brady, Michael Jordan and others, Patrick Mahomes has never leaned into slights. Sunday, against the Bengals and Joe...

Sports2 hours ago

Patrick Reed: ‘It’s not like I tried to assassinate Rory McIlroy’

In less than a day Patrick Reed went from calling Rory McIlroy “an immature child” to praising the world No...

Sports3 hours ago

Jack Edwards apologizes to Pat Maroon for body-shaming comments

The Bruins broadcaster apologized to Maroon face to face ahead of Thursday's game in Tampa.

Sports3 hours ago

Ole Miss quarterback room is packed, Brian Kelly accidentally got an extra million dollars & should scholarships be removed from college sports?

Dan Wetzel, SI’s Pat Forde & SI’s Ross Dellenger react to a new in-depth article that covered the North Carolina...

Sports4 hours ago

Astros hire Braves VP Dana Brown, who becomes MLB’s only Black GM

The Braves drafted the 2022 NL Rookie of the Year and the runner-up under Brown.

Technology Hot News

Technology1 week ago

Led by "Amazon" and "Microsoft" .. the technology giants are planning to lay off 64,000 employees

After 10 years of driving the stock market bull run, big tech companies are racing to downsize staff to adapt...

Technology1 week ago

Apple introduces MacBooks with new M2 processors

Yesterday, Tuesday, Apple unveiled MacBooks powered by the new, faster “M2 Pro” and “M2 Max” processor chips, in a surprise...

Technology1 week ago

All you need to know about the upcoming Galaxy S23 phones from Samsung

Samsung has officially announced that the (Galaxy Unpacked 2023) event will be held this year on Wednesday, February 1, which...

Technology1 week ago

FTX Exchange Announces Hacking and Stolen $415 Million in Cryptocurrency

Bankrupt American cryptocurrency firm FTX announced today, Wednesday, that $415 million in cryptocurrency has been hacked and stolen from the...

Technology1 week ago

Because of a "fraudulent tweet"… Elon Musk's trial begins

Elon Musk's trial began Tuesday in San Francisco with the selection of jury members who will have to decide whether...

Technology1 week ago

An electric spoon replaces salt and spices, but with conditions

Experts have developed an electric spoon that is able to replace spices and flavors and affect the taste buds in...

Technology2 weeks ago

The biggest dangers of using tracking devices.. so you can escape?

If you spot an unknown Bluetooth tagging device, there are ways to disable the device so it can't track your...

Technology2 weeks ago

New Twitter.. For You tab to web version

The Twitter platform announced that it will bring the new tab (For You), which launched last Tuesday for iPhones and...