Connect with us

World

Tennessee Supreme Court strikes down juvenile life sentence law

News Agencies

Published

on

The Tennessee Supreme Court building: The building was completed in 1937 and is now on the National Register of Historic Places. It is used by the Tennessee Supreme Court, Court of Appeals and Court of Criminal Appeals, and is home to a museum of state court history. Source: https://www.tn.gov/museum

The Tennessee Supreme Court building: The building was completed in 1937 and is now on the National Register of Historic Places. It is used by the Tennessee Supreme Court, Court of Appeals and Court of Criminal Appeals, and is home to a museum of state court history. Source: https://www.tn.gov/museum

Juveniles convicted of first-degree murder no longer face a mandatory 51-year sentence after the Tennessee Supreme Court on Friday found the law violates the Eighth Amendment.

It was the case of Tyshon Booker, 16 at the time of his arrest, that brought the issue to the high court’s attention. He was convicted of first-degree murder after fatally shooting G’Metrik Caldwell, 26, in Knoxville in 2015. He was tried as an adult.

Until now, Tennessee’s mandatory sentence for juveniles was the strictest in the country by more than 10 years. A person convicted of first-degree murder had to serve at least 51 years of a 60-year “life” sentence before being eligible for parole.

But under the Eighth Amendment, applying the heavy sentence to a juvenile without a mechanism for judicial discretion amounts to cruel and unusual punishment, the state’s highest court found, striking down the 1995 law to revert to an earlier version.

Tennessee out of step with nation

A 2019 investigation by The Tennessean, cited in Friday’s ruling, found more than 100 incarcerated Tennesseans serving life sentences for crimes committed as children. The law, out of step with the rest of the nation, gained attention through the case of Cyntoia Brown.

Convicted in the murder of a 42-year-old Nashville real estate agent when she was 16, Brown faced the mandatory minimum of 51 years.

In January 2019, outgoing Gov. Bill Haslam granted her clemency, calling her sentence “too harsh.”

In his decision to grant Brown’s early release, Haslam acknowledged her case was not unique and said he hoped “serious consideration of additional reforms will continue, especially with respect to the sentencing of juveniles.”

Cyntoia Brown-Long speaks about her memoir, Free Cyntoia, at Christ Church Cathedral in Nashville, Tenn., Wednesday, Oct. 23, 2019.

Cyntoia Brown-Long speaks about her memoir, Free Cyntoia, at Christ Church Cathedral in Nashville, Tenn., Wednesday, Oct. 23, 2019.

Friday’s ruling

The ruling leaves space for judges to adjust sentences for juveniles convicted of first-degree murder. It also opens the door for the legislature to review the criminal code, should lawmakers wish to lay out a new, constitutional sentencing scheme for juvenile defendants.

Justice Sharon G. Lee, who announced this week she plans to retire in August, penned the majority opinion. She was joined by Special Justice William C. Koch and Justice Holly Kirby, who issued an additional concurring opinion.

In it, she noted that courts, including the U.S. Supreme Court, have held that juveniles are not the same as adults when it comes to both decision-making that leads to criminal behavior and response to punishment.

The law “lacks individualized sentencing, which serves as a bulwark against disproportionate punishment, and it goes beyond what is necessary to accomplish legitimate penological objectives,” she wrote.

Dissent claims court is policy-making

Dissenting, Justice Jeffrey S. Bivins argued the ruling oversteps the authority of the courts. Joined by Chief Justice Roger A. Page, he said he found the majority’s argument “sound” policy — but he argued the court should not make policy.

Both Lee and Kirby were quick to rebut his approach in their opinions.

The courts have a duty, Lee wrote, to not “ignore an injustice” in the court’s role of upholding the state and federal constitutions.

Kirby, meanwhile, defended the majority’s ruling in light of the national trend away from harsh life sentences for juveniles. She said Bivins was “shrugging off” vital information.

“This is weak tea,” she wrote.

Booker was not resentenced under the ruling; his prison sentence remains 60 years.

But for the first time, he can expect to one day, between 25 and 36 years into his sentence, receive an individualized parole hearing where his age, rehabilitation and other circumstances can be considered.

He has a chance to get out of prison before he turns 45.

This article originally appeared on Nashville Tennessean: Tennessee Supreme Court strikes down juvenile life sentence law

Continue Reading
Advertisement

Breaking News

Advertisement

Editor Pick’s

Latest Entertainment

Entertainment2 hours ago

Man arrested in fatal shooting of Migos rapper Takeoff

HOUSTON (AP) — Police have arrested a 33-year-old man in the fatal shooting of rapper Takeoff, who was killed last...

Entertainment2 hours ago

Balenciaga outlines organizational changes after campaign backlash, ‘outraged’ Kim Kardashian

Balenciaga ambassador Kim Kardashian is speaking out after the luxury fashion house was embroiled in controversy for its recent holiday...

Entertainment2 hours ago

Backstreet Boys talk holidays, ‘leaning on one another’ during tough times, and fond childhood Christmas memory of Aaron Carter

The Backstreet Boys’ Nick Carter, Howie Dorough, AJ McLean, Brian Littrell, and Kevin Richardson. (Photo: JCPenney) The Backstreet Boys just...

Entertainment2 hours ago

Backstreet Boys talk holidays, ‘leaning on one another’ during tough times, and sweet childhood Christmas memory of Aaron Carter

The Backstreet Boys’ Nick Carter, Howie Dorough, AJ McLean, Brian Littrell, and Kevin Richardson. (Photo: JCPenney) The Backstreet Boys just...

Entertainment3 hours ago

Role Recall: David Harbour on famed director who told him to act ‘more handsome,’ his ‘Stranger Things’ breakout and hard ‘Hellboy’ lessons

David Harbour attends the premiere of Universal Pictures’ Violent Night at TCL Chinese Theatre on Nov. 29, 2022 in Hollywood,...

Entertainment3 hours ago

Margot Robbie’s ‘Pirates of the Caribbean’ Film Not Entirely Dead, Says Jerry Bruckheimer: ‘The Script Will Come Forward’ at Some Point

Margot Robbie’s female-led “Pirates of the Caribbean” spinoff might not be dead after all. The Oscar nominee claimed last month...

Entertainment5 hours ago

Jim Parsons on the new LGBTQ love story ‘Spoiler Alert’ and his bumpy exit from ‘The Big Bang Theory’: ‘I was doing what I had to do’

Jim Parsons as Michael and Ben Aldridge as Kit in Spoiler Alert. (Photo: Linda Kallerus/Focus Features/Courtesy Everett Collection) Earlier this...

Entertainment5 hours ago

New York Film Critics 2022: ‘Tar’ Named Best Film

Todd Field’s dark drama “Tár” has been named the best film of 2022 by the New York Film Critics Circle,...

Latest Sports

Technology Hot News

Is Elon Musk Really Going to Buy Twitter? Is Elon Musk Really Going to Buy Twitter?
Technology1 month ago

Is Elon Musk Really Going to Buy Twitter?

Elon Musk, the owner of the electric car company Tesla, CEO of SpaceX, and the richest man in the world,...

WhatsApp services were affected across Pakistan, restored after 2 hours WhatsApp services were affected across Pakistan, restored after 2 hours
Technology1 month ago

WhatsApp services were affected across Pakistan, restored after 2 hours

WhatsApp services were affected in various countries of the world, including Pakistan, and India due to this users were facing...

Bitcoin vs Litecoin: A guide to understanding cryptocurrencies Bitcoin vs Litecoin: A guide to understanding cryptocurrencies
Technology2 months ago

Bitcoin vs Litecoin: A guide to understanding cryptocurrencies

Cryptocurrencies currently occupy an odd place in society. They are no longer the super niche bizarre currency beloved by tech...

Personal data of people is selling on Google Play and Google Ads Personal data of people is selling on Google Play and Google Ads
Editor Picks3 months ago

Personal data of people are sold on Google Play and Google Ads

It’s been two to three years since Google has been unknowingly hosting multiple apps from malicious actors who sell personal...

Protonmail is down a second time in the past 24 hours Protonmail is down a second time in the past 24 hours
Technology5 months ago

Protonmail is down a second time in the past 24 hours

An end-to-end encrypted email service Protonmail is down a second time in the past 24 hours, netizens reported on social...

What's better for the student: a tablet or a laptop What's better for the student: a tablet or a laptop
Technology6 months ago

What’s better for the student: a tablet or a laptop

Some analysts argue that computers have outlived their usefulness. There is some truth in this: PC and laptop sales are...

Tesla founder Elon Musk holds the Twitter deal temporary Tesla founder Elon Musk holds the Twitter deal temporary
Technology7 months ago

Tesla founder Elon Musk holds the Twitter deal temporary

USA: Elon Musk, the founder of companies like Tesla and SpaceX, can actually buy anything in the world. Last month,...

How Zafar Supari is utilizing his ability on Snapchat? How Zafar Supari is utilizing his ability on Snapchat?
Technology7 months ago

How Zafar Supari is utilizing his ability on Snapchat?

Pakistan: Zafar Supari a public figure, businessman, and social media sensation has crossed one hundred thirty-three thousand 133k subscribers on...