Connect with us

Europe

Zimbabwe without Robert Mugabe: What has changed?

News Agencies

Published

on

Zimbabwe without Robert Mugabe: What has changed?
Robert Mugabe calls on Zanu-PF supporters in 2017 to back Grace Mugabe's bid to become the party's next vice-president.

Robert Mugabe was president for 37 years until 2017

A climate of fear still lingers in Zimbabwe, five years after long-time ruler Robert Mugabe was deposed. As the country marks this milestone, few people are willing to speak openly about whether the government that took power has honoured its promise of transformation, either in terms of raising living standards or guaranteeing human rights.

“I mind my own business,” one street vendor tells the BBC, who does not want to be named. “People who speak their minds – some end up in prison. So, I keep things to myself and do what I have to do to survive.”

Little has changed in this regard since President Mugabe’s departure. Many ordinary people and critics still face arrest for insulting the president, say human rights lawyers.

Advertisement

Tendai (not his real name) sells groceries out of his car boot – washing powder, deodorant, snacks, and cooking oil are all neatly stacked up. Even though he is a university graduate with a double major in marketing and human resources management, he says being a street vendor is the only way he can earn his living because there are no jobs available.

“Things are the same or even worse since Robert Mugabe left. But while it might sound far-fetched, I still have hope about the future,” he adds.

Inflation today is 268% – many times higher than it was when Mr Mugabe left office, according to data from Zimbabwe’s national statistics body. Meanwhile, the proportion of Zimbabweans in extreme poverty has almost doubled – from 30% in 2017 to 50% during the coronavirus pandemic, says the World Bank.

Advertisement

This has driven more people into desperation.

Harare is teeming with informal traders, including more and more middle-class people selling goods from their cars. One woman sells fresh meat out of plastic bins in her van, to customers who arrive on foot or by car for smaller and smaller rations of meat – some paying as little as $0.50 (£0.42) at a time.

“Personally, I wasn’t one of the people who was happy when Mugabe resigned. People didn’t know that they were celebrating coming disaster,” the meat vendor tells the BBC.

Advertisement

Women holding a flag of Zimbabwe take part in a demonstration of University of Zimbabwe's students, on 20 November 2017 in Harare, as pressure builds on Zimbabwe's President Robert Mugabe to resign and after criticism of his wife Grace.

Zimbabweans filled the capital’s streets before and after the announcement

“They thought after he left they would have bread with margarine and jam, eggs and milk – but that isn’t what has happened.”

Praise and promises

Harare’s streets erupted as people celebrated Mr Mugabe’s resignation on 21 November 2017. A week earlier tanks had rolled onto the capital’s streets as the military seized the public broadcaster and placed the 93-year-old president under house arrest.

Advertisement

Mr Mugabe’s former vice-president, Emmerson Mnangagwa, emerged as the hero who stood up to the strongman. He vowed to end poisonous and polarising domestic politics, to turn around the economy and repair fractured relations with Western nations.

However, sceptics pointed out that he had worked closely with Mr Mugabe for many years and had been accused of playing an instrumental role in some of the worst atrocities of the Mugabe era, and wondered whether he was really the man to deliver change. Mr Mugabe’s Zanu-PF party remained in power.

“I went into government because I loved my country and not the coup,” said award-winning author and lawyer Petina Gappah, during an online discussion held by political think-tank SAPES Trust to review the post-coup era.

Advertisement

She had been recruited as an advisor on international re-engagement in the ministry of foreign affairs but lasted just 18 months. She says she left in sorrow, not in anger and in disappointment, not bitterness.

Petina Gappah poses for a portrait in 2010.

“I loved my country and not the coup,” says award-winning author and lawyer Petina Gappah

“Some leaders called it a miracle, we had sense that that something fresh was coming – unfortunately it didn’t come,” she said.

Last week’s visit by a Commonwealth delegation considering Zimbabwe’s readmission suggests there has been a positive shift since President Mugabe left. Such a visit would previously have been unthinkable.

Advertisement

Zimbabwe pulled out of the body in 2003 blaming what it called an “Anglo-Saxon unholy alliance against Zimbabwe”. The year before, Zimbabwe had been suspended for human rights violations including violent takeovers of white-owned farms and the persecution of opposition members.

Zimbabwe’s re-entry to the Commonwealth would be a symbolic win for President Mnangagwa’s government – a sign that its quarrel with the UK over land was over, analysts have told Gappah.

The main opposition party – the Citizen’s Coalition for Change (CCC) – wants pre-conditions set before Zimbabwe before can re-join, citing the continuing persecution of its members, journalists and other government critics.

Advertisement

In the week of the Commonwealth visit, 15 CCC members including member of parliament Godfrey Sithole were finally released on bail after spending five months in jail for allegedly inciting public violence in clashes with government supporters in Nyatsime, south of Harare, which they say are politically motivated. Job Sikhala, another legislator, remains behind bars on the same charges.

While the Commonwealth delegation led by assistant secretary general Luis Franceschi said Zimbabwe had made “very impressive progress” in meeting the conditions, member countries will have to consider whether economic, human rights and electoral reforms are sufficient for readmission.

At this stage, the Zimbabwean government remains hopeful. “We have done everything that is possible to be readmitted – there are countries in the Commonwealth that are comparable to us,” says Zanu-PF spokesman Nick Mangwana.

Advertisement

Sensitive to bigger business

However, some businesses say there has been a positive shift. GDP is up from $17.5bn (£14.8bn) in 2017, to $20.2bn last year.

“This government is more sensitive to the needs of business. They could do more but you can’t compare it to the previous government,” says Kurai Matsheza, who is the president of the Confederation of Zimbabwe Industries manufacturing lobby.

He says there are fewer company closures than in the Mugabe era, adding, “the policy shifts, the price controls are not at the same level they used to be”.

Advertisement

The government has attracted hundreds of millions of dollars in investment, mainly in mining. Platinum giant Zimplats will invest $1.8bn over the next 10 years, following negotiations with government. Meanwhile, Chinese miner Zhejiang Huayou Cobalt is set to invest $300m in its lithium mine.

A steel project that stalled under Mugabe has been revived. The horticulture industry that had collapsed is now back following investment in irrigation. Wheat production is at a 17-year high. Roads and dams are being repaired and constructed.

However, this is not yet translating into enough jobs to prevent young Zimbabweans from doing everything they can to go elsewhere to make lives for themselves.

Advertisement
A customer buys cooking oil at a stall where smaller than standard measures of cooking oil is sold at Harare Mbare Musika marketplace in 2019.

Bigger businesses may be faring better but inflation is hurting informal traders

So what is the government doing about it?

“Now 50% percent of revenue is going into capital investment – to improve lives you have to improve outcomes so government had to put in enablers, which is infrastructure,” says government spokesman Mr Mangwana.

“The Word Bank says the country has reached middle-income status, which means incomes have improved. We have not arrived at our destination, what we have is work in progress,” he adds.

Advertisement

But Ranga Mberi, editor of business news website Newzwire, says more is needed. “While it is good to talk about growth and investment in mining, what matters is what’s on the food table and in people’s pockets.”

“Inflation is the big issue that people will judge him [Mnangagwa] by,” he adds.

“The test is that everything has to translate to full stomachs. And that is the big test for Mr Mnangagwa going into 2023.”

Advertisement
Continue Reading
Advertisement

Advertisement

Breaking News

Editor Pick’s

Latest Entertainment

Chris Brown apologizes to Robert Glasper for social outburst after losing at the Grammys Chris Brown apologizes to Robert Glasper for social outburst after losing at the Grammys
Entertainment3 hours ago

Chris Brown apologizes to Robert Glasper for social outburst after losing at the Grammys

Chris Brown is sorry for being a sore loser at the Grammy Awards. The singer, 33, took to Instagram on...

I Know What You Did Last Summer sequel with original stars in the works at Sony I Know What You Did Last Summer sequel with original stars in the works at Sony
Entertainment4 hours ago

I Know What You Did Last Summer sequel with original stars in the works at Sony

Another summer, another hook-wielding psycho killer — and maybe some familiar faces too. More than 25 years after I Know...

Could 'The Last of Us' finale beat the Oscars in the ratings? We break down the numbers Could 'The Last of Us' finale beat the Oscars in the ratings? We break down the numbers
Entertainment4 hours ago

Could ‘The Last of Us’ finale beat the Oscars in the ratings? We break down the numbers

The fungal zombies are coming for the Oscars. In a programming matchup that’s certain to create an agonizing Sophie’s choice...

Will Smith Was Going to Be a Surprise Grammys Performer — but Had to Drop Out for 'Bad Boys 4' Will Smith Was Going to Be a Surprise Grammys Performer — but Had to Drop Out for 'Bad Boys 4'
Entertainment6 hours ago

Will Smith Was Going to Be a Surprise Grammys Performer — but Had to Drop Out for ‘Bad Boys 4’

Will Smith and Martin Lawrence Confirm Bad Boys 4 Is in the Works: ‘It’s Official, Y’all!’ Will Smith/Instagram Will Smith...

Ben Affleck miserable at the Grammys? Jennifer Lopez says she had 'the best time' with him Ben Affleck miserable at the Grammys? Jennifer Lopez says she had 'the best time' with him
Entertainment6 hours ago

Ben Affleck miserable at the Grammys? Jennifer Lopez says she had ‘the best time’ with him

Jennifer Lopez and Ben Affleck at the 65th Grammy Awards at Crypto.com Arena on February 05, 2023 in Los Angeles,...

David Bowie Producer Tony Visconti Rejects Harry Styles Comparisons David Bowie Producer Tony Visconti Rejects Harry Styles Comparisons
Entertainment10 hours ago

David Bowie Producer Tony Visconti Rejects Harry Styles Comparisons

The post David Bowie Producer Tony Visconti Rejects Harry Styles Comparisons appeared first on Consequence. Harry Styles might be one...

Maria Shriver talks about feeling 'invisible' during Arnold Schwarzenegger marriage Maria Shriver talks about feeling 'invisible' during Arnold Schwarzenegger marriage
Entertainment10 hours ago

Maria Shriver talks about feeling ‘invisible’ during Arnold Schwarzenegger marriage

Maria Shriver talks about her ‘journey to re-evaluate everything in my life’ after her marriage toArnold Schwarzenegger ended. (Photo: Bonnie...

Disney removes 'Simpsons' episode with Chinese 'forced labor camps' reference from Hong Kong streaming service Disney removes 'Simpsons' episode with Chinese 'forced labor camps' reference from Hong Kong streaming service
Entertainment10 hours ago

Disney removes ‘Simpsons’ episode with Chinese ‘forced labor camps’ reference from Hong Kong streaming service

A scene from The Simpsons episode “One Angry Lisa,” which has reportedly been removed from streaming services in Hong Kong....

Advertisement

Latest Sports

Patriots show willingness to spend out of coaching hole with Adrian Klemm hire Patriots show willingness to spend out of coaching hole with Adrian Klemm hire
Sports38 mins ago

Patriots show willingness to spend out of coaching hole with Adrian Klemm hire

The Patriots have, on a few occasions, spent big to fix glaring roster holes. This offseason is different, writes Phil...

Nick Sirianni on being fired by Andy Reid: You always have this little chip on your shoulder Nick Sirianni on being fired by Andy Reid: You always have this little chip on your shoulder
Sports1 hour ago

Nick Sirianni on being fired by Andy Reid: You always have this little chip on your shoulder

After the Chiefs beat the Bengals in the AFC Championship Game, it was hard to miss people talking about the...

Steph Curry injury boils down to high-ankle sprain variant, doctor clarifies Steph Curry injury boils down to high-ankle sprain variant, doctor clarifies
Sports2 hours ago

Steph Curry injury boils down to high-ankle sprain variant, doctor clarifies

What exactly did that Steph Curry injury update mean? Dr. Seth Sherman of Stanford Medicine clarified any lingering questions.

What Chris Partridge's return to Michigan means for future staff What Chris Partridge's return to Michigan means for future staff
Sports2 hours ago

What Chris Partridge’s return to Michigan means for future staff

What we know is Chris Partridge is returning to Ann Arbor to coach with the Michigan Wolverines. First, it's important...

It's official: We know how long the 13th hole will play at this year's Masters It's official: We know how long the 13th hole will play at this year's Masters
Sports2 hours ago

It’s official: We know how long the 13th hole will play at this year’s Masters

The Masters Tournament released its annual media guide on Monday, and inside that are the listed yardages for this year’s...

Follow live: Super Bowl Opening Night Follow live: Super Bowl Opening Night
Sports3 hours ago

Follow live: Super Bowl Opening Night

Yahoo Sports is on the scene in Arizona, so come hang out with us as fans and media get to...

NASCAR driver Kyle Busch arrested in Mexico in January for handgun possession NASCAR driver Kyle Busch arrested in Mexico in January for handgun possession
Sports3 hours ago

NASCAR driver Kyle Busch arrested in Mexico in January for handgun possession

Busch, 37, was arrested on Jan. 27. He finished third in Sunday's exhibition opener for the 2023 NASCAR Cup Series...

The Super Bowl's 1st play is usually easy money The Super Bowl's 1st play is usually easy money
Sports4 hours ago

The Super Bowl’s 1st play is usually easy money

Picking the opening kickoff of the Super Bowl to be a touchback is available at BetMGM for plus money and...

Technology Hot News

Led by "Amazon" and "Microsoft" . Led by "Amazon" and "Microsoft" .
Technology3 weeks ago

Led by "Amazon" and "Microsoft" .. the technology giants are planning to lay off 64,000 employees

After 10 years of driving the stock market bull run, big tech companies are racing to downsize staff to adapt...

Apple introduces MacBooks with new M2 processors Apple introduces MacBooks with new M2 processors
Technology3 weeks ago

Apple introduces MacBooks with new M2 processors

Yesterday, Tuesday, Apple unveiled MacBooks powered by the new, faster “M2 Pro” and “M2 Max” processor chips, in a surprise...

All you need to know about the upcoming Galaxy S23 phones from Samsung All you need to know about the upcoming Galaxy S23 phones from Samsung
Technology3 weeks ago

All you need to know about the upcoming Galaxy S23 phones from Samsung

Samsung has officially announced that the (Galaxy Unpacked 2023) event will be held this year on Wednesday, February 1, which...

FTX Exchange Announces Hacking and Stolen $415 Million in Cryptocurrency FTX Exchange Announces Hacking and Stolen $415 Million in Cryptocurrency
Technology3 weeks ago

FTX Exchange Announces Hacking and Stolen $415 Million in Cryptocurrency

Bankrupt American cryptocurrency firm FTX announced today, Wednesday, that $415 million in cryptocurrency has been hacked and stolen from the...

Because of a "fraudulent tweet".. Because of a "fraudulent tweet"..
Technology3 weeks ago

Because of a "fraudulent tweet"… Elon Musk's trial begins

Elon Musk's trial began Tuesday in San Francisco with the selection of jury members who will have to decide whether...

An electric spoon replaces salt and spices, but with conditions An electric spoon replaces salt and spices, but with conditions
Technology3 weeks ago

An electric spoon replaces salt and spices, but with conditions

Experts have developed an electric spoon that is able to replace spices and flavors and affect the taste buds in...

The biggest dangers of using tracking devices. The biggest dangers of using tracking devices.
Technology3 weeks ago

The biggest dangers of using tracking devices.. so you can escape?

If you spot an unknown Bluetooth tagging device, there are ways to disable the device so it can't track your...

New Twitter. New Twitter.
Technology3 weeks ago

New Twitter.. For You tab to web version

The Twitter platform announced that it will bring the new tab (For You), which launched last Tuesday for iPhones and...

Advertisement